Lessons from
Karen Klein’s Bullies
This
morning, I watched the entire video of students from a school in upstate New
York teasing Karen Klein, their 68-year-old bus aide. The group of kids bullied the woman, calling
her a “fat ass,” throwing around the f-bomb, sexually harassing her, and even
discussing what it would be like to stab her.
I can’t help but think that similar behavior goes on when the cameras
aren’t running, and when the victim isn’t a 68-year-old woman but is instead a
vulnerable child.
Living
in a state (NJ) with the nation’s toughest anti-bullying legislation, I often
hear people complain that we as a country are overreacting to the commonplace
cycle of teasing that all kids must endure.
Dealing with bullying has been described as everything from a “rite of
passage” to a natural part of childhood that helps individuals build thicker
skins and stand up for themselves.
To
an extent, this is true. My grandparents
survived the bullying of their day. My
parents also turned out fine. True, kids
need to learn how to navigate their own battles. And when there is no adult around, they
will. But we can’t expect a child in a
similar situation as Karen Klein to stand up for himself. If you think that what Karen went through helps
build character, you’re wrong.
Part
of the resistance to anti-bullying efforts comes from a lack of understanding
of what bullying is. There’s a difference
between the harassment, intimidation & bullying we all witnessed in the
Karen Klein video and ordinary teasing.
The former often is persistent, evokes race, ethnicity, sexual identity,
and weight in an attempt to show dominance, while the latter is often playful
and fleeting. The other part of the resistance comes from the unfair burden the
legislation in New Jersey places on schools.
This is true, but for too long individuals in power took the “right of
passage” approach and did not take students’ cries for help seriously.
But
beyond the semantics and the overbearing laws, we all can take steps to decrease
bullying in our society. What is most
alarming in the video is that not one individual had the courage to stand up
for Karen. Could the bus driver hear
what was occurring? What about the other
students on the bus?
As
we move beyond yet another bullying incident, some will still say that bullying
builds character, and others will say that the future generation of kids are
disrespectful and worse than ever. Both
claims, though, do nothing to solve the problem. Instead, parents, teachers, and communities
need to instill in their children a sense of compassion and the ability to
think independently. I have no doubt
that my 12-year-old sister Natalie would have been devastated to witness what
happened to Karen Klein. I have no doubt
that she would have showed courage by standing up for her. Sometimes that’s all it takes.